1-805-845-4171
220 E. Cota St.
Santa Barbara, CA 93101

THE GREAT GRAIN DEBATE. PLEASE READ.

Strap in folks, this is going to be a bit of a long one.

Last Thursday night at our Whole Life Challenge kick off seminar, there was a very emotional question asked about us proving what we believe to be true about nutrition – grains especially.

I often tell people in their Intro’s that we sometime find it easier to change someone’s religion than change their diet. Food is woven into the fabric of our family history, our relationships, our geographic pasts and travels, and our culture.

To change what we eat, takes not only a leap of faith, but equal faith that alienation or separation from the above mentioned won’t happen with the change of diet. Eric said it best when he stated truthfully that he was worried his friends wouldn’t hang out with him if he went Zone or Paleo.

So let’s talk about the grain issue. I was asked to come up with peer-reviewed studies to “prove” that eating grains was harmful to your health. Below are the best studies that I found both for and against ingesting grains, as well as some other resources for and against.

Against:

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19755695

http://robbwolf.com/2011/01/12/hey-robb-this-person-said-gluten-free-diets-are-bogus/

http://www.wheatbellyblog.com/success-stories/ (feel free to read the book Wheat Belly)

http://www.direct-ms.org/sites/default/files/Fasano%20Celiac%20other%20autoimmune%20disease.pdf

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/dr-mark-hyman/wheat-gluten_b_1274872.html

http://www.nograinconvert.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/09/celiac-disease-surprises.pdf

http://www.totalhealthbreakthroughs.com/2009/02/heart-surgeon-admits-huge-mistake/

http://www.totalhealthbreakthroughs.com/2009/02/heart-surgeon-admits-huge-mistake-part-2/

www.deflame.com

http://www.ajcn.org/content/81/2/341.full

http://www.wellsphere.com/add-adhd-article/gluten-celiac-migraine-add-adhd-connections-1/472372

For:

http://www.wholegrainscouncil.org/files/SlavinArticle0504.pdf

http://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2012/06/time-to-retire-the-low-carb-diet-fad/258343/

http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/whole-grains/NU00204

http://www.hsph.harvard.edu/nutritionsource/what-should-you-eat/health-gains-from-whole-grains/

http://archinte.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=227566

http://health.usnews.com/usnews/health/healthday/071022/whole-grains-do-a-heart-good.htm

 

As with most dietary issues, all kinds of factors go into each outcome, as well as the studies. Thus us presenting both sides of the coin. (do some research on eggs, or on dairy and you’ll get equally conflicting results)

So there you have it. Sort of. Believe it or not, it was hard to find exact studies either way. There were a ton of people’s opinions; many of them highly respected in their fields, but not a lot of true, peer-reviewed, double blind studies. There is also some reading between the lines with outcomes – replacing white flour, sugary cereals, and the like with either whole grains or no grains will give you a positive outcome in comparison to the old eating habits. Also, many people on both sides of the fence have books and products to sell you backing up their opinions.

That all being said, here’s our official take on grains and how we’ve developed it.

I believe that what I see, hear, and experience first hand in real life, far outweighs what was created in someone’s else’s lab or in a study. After Eric and I have run over 100 people through various dietary challenges at CPC and Ali and I have run equal numbers of people through grain elimination periods in our acupuncture practice, we have never had anyone come back to us and report the following:

  • Sinus flare up
  • Asthma flare ups
  • Migraines
  • Allergic eye issues
  • Eczema flare ups
  • Psoriasis flare ups
  • Wheezing
  • Fatigue
  • Gastrointesinal issues such as diarrhea, constipation, gas, irritable bowel
  • Menstrual issues such as cramping, emotional swings, pain and bloating
  • Menopausal issues such as night sweats, mood swings
  • Insomnia
  • Depression
  • Aspergers/ ADHD increasing
  • Arthritis pain increaseing
  • Fibromyalgia worsening
  • Weight gains
  • And more.

Now take a look at the above list and know that we’ve had people come back to us and report firsthand that every single one of those ailments had either significantly lessened in either frequency and/or intensity or completely resolved themselves – all after grains were eliminated from their diets for under 30 days. This is in addition to significantly more people that we’ve talked to from other gyms.

Is this a direct correlation that we could prove in a court of law or under academic or scientific scrutiny? Not at all. Is it enough for us as coaches and for me as a health practitioner? Absolutely.

But what about the French? Or the Japanese? Or any other country that eats grains and seems to be doing better than we are health wise? This is also a question that we get from time to time so I’ll address it.

How are people in those cultures faring better than Americans when they eat what we tell you not to? Simple – we have no idea. My best educated guess is that through a combination of both genetics but more importantly lifestyle and other dietary choices, people in the above mentioned countries are not as susceptible to the diseases that we are here in the U.S.

It may not actually just be a singular grain, or a singular dairy isolate that’s getting us, but more so the prevalence of extremely low quality food (especially in lower income areas where the disease rates are the highest), the prevalence of fast food and soda, coupled with a sedentary lifestyle that’s kicking the shit out the collective American health. How hard has it been for any of you to find ways to eat three to five meals a day without any single product with wheat in it? Do you think you shop like the rest of America? Me either.

Yes, the French eat bread and cheese while washing it down with wine and cigarettes. They also walk a lot more than we do and legally aren’t allowed to work more than 35 hours a week (this gives them more time to practice saying “I surrender” in German). Virtually every Japanese male smokes cigarettes. They also walk a ton and eat fish and seaweed at almost every meal. Health is hardly ever the response to one isolated aspect.

Do we want you to take what we tell you with blind faith? Absolutely not, thus the point of this and every challenge putting you at the forefront of the experimentation. Test this out for yourselves, do your own due diligence and see if your body reacts positively or negatively.

At the end of the month, if you feel great, stick with it. If you feel like crap, go back to eating how you used to secure in knowing that despite what other people say, us included, you know your body and it’s preferences.

Traver & Eric

Today’s Workout:
10 Min to find max height box jump

Bench Press
5-5-5-5-5 then…
ME set at 50% of last round of 5

3 Rounds FT:
200 m Farmers Carry
50 double unders

 

 


8 comments
Chris Mobley
Chris Mobley

Was it the French or the Italians who invented espresso? Not sure, although espresso sounds suspiciously Italian. Each record gives us different answers. Some record says, the first espresso coffee maker was invented by Louis Bernard Babaut in 1822 along with Edward Santais, who was the marketer of machine in 1843. It got the publicity in 1855 at the Universal Exposition in Paris. According to the records, in an hour a coffee maker can produce one thousand cups of espresso coffee using steam to force water through coffee held in the filter. Every new invention has to bear risk and this espresso coffee maker was not an exception. It had a tendency to blow from time to time and sometimes it burned the coffee too. The initial espresso coffee makers weren't so easy to use. Operating them required some degree of skill and it left plenty of room for diversity. The intensity of the heat & the length of time were controlled by the operator and the water valve remained open. The coffee users could put in less coffee grounds & obtain strong coffee or use more water & get a diluted one. Further records credit Luigi Bezzera, a manufacturer, with the invention of Espresso in 1903. Bezzera wanted to make coffee faster, so he added more pressure due to which 'Voila' the Fast Coffee Machine was born. This machine made coffee faster and better than any other machine. The machine invented by Bezzera used the force of steam to push water through a fixed filter containing coffee. Even though Bezzera was skilled in inventing, he was lacking in the marketing talent to promote his creation. In 1905, Desidero Pavoni purchased the rights of the espresso machine and the product was successfully marketed, changing the way everyone drank coffee. The coffee makers were sold throughout Europe by Pavoni. Franceso Illy created the first automatic espresso coffee maker. In 1935, Illeta invented the coffee maker and used compressed air instead of steam for his machine. The problem of exploding espresso coffee makers was solved by this machine & gave a more stable result. The espresso coffee maker invented by Achille's Gaggia bears his name in 1945. The lever action was included in his invention and even today we can get the modern versions of both Illeta and Gaggia espresso coffee makers. An electric rotating pump was created by Ernest Valente in 1950. The pump allowed a continuous, even flow of water through the coffee maker. In 1970's, Illy went on to simplify the espresso coffee maker process, when he introduced a machine that combined the best parts of previous espresso coffee maker methods. His machine used double filters, which costs less than other coffee makers and was simple to use. Super automatic espresso coffee makers were born in the 70's. Now they are the standard coffee makers in many countries. The machines continue to evolve. The debate over which methods and which machines produce the best espresso will be going on as long as people continue to enjoy their cup of Joe. However, espresso is old school-- all true coffee cognoscenti know that to get the best coffee flavor from the best single-source beans you use: fresh, light to medium roasted beans ground using a mill grinder, filtered water at 190 to 200 deg F (not boiling!) in a French Press, grounds steeped for about 4 minutes, then drink it black. Pure coffee goodness. So we owe the French for the very best coffee experience after all.

Sarah S.
Sarah S.

Very well said, guys. I obviously don't speak for everyone, but over the course of my majorly geeky life of learning shit, the foremost true thing has always been: the more you know, the more you realize you don't actually know all that much. Nutritional science has long been impeded by the insufficient mathematical precision afforded it from biology. Lucky for people who like to know things, biomath is trending and maybe one day in the not so distant future, we'll have models rigorous enough to map the myriad chemical reactions involved in nutrient consumption, while factoring in genetic predisposition. These things take time to understand. A personal anecdote: really trivial stuff that I worked on in 2009 on protein knotting is juuuuuuuuuuust now, 3 years and multiple grad student theses later, conclusive enough to publish in the AMS monthly. And it's not even all that conclusive. Feynman said something to the effect of, "If you think science is certain - that's just an error on your part." Put loosely: shit's complicated. Until you know that you know something, experimentation reigns supreme. You get to play scientist - which is FUN, right? It's sort of like when you were a kid and you would use your pocket knife to slice your finger open so that you could look at your own blood under the lens of your microscope, only it hopefully involves less blood loss and more rippling abdominals. If we stop trying to say that any particular thing is true forever and ever, under all circumstances, no matter what - THE END, and we instead work to find best-fit models, it takes some of the heat out of this conversation. Which is exactly what this post says and does, and thus, bravo.

Bowers
Bowers

How does one reconcile their love of french wine, distaste for crousaints, love of espresso and distaste for incompetent military strategy? I prefer to remember the French supporting our founding fathers rather than the Maginot Line. Imagine the French Riveria rather than the undercity of Paris. Start my morning sipping a delicious espresso instead of getting crousaint flakes all over a nice shirt. There are some things that I love about the French. Gluten and Military Prowess are not included.

jonathan wang
jonathan wang

Thanks for this post! I'll get to reading all the links later this evening. For me, it has been difficult reconciling my Chinese heritage and not eating steamed rice (or any other dish at a typical Chinese restaurant). It literally feels like I am giving up a part of myself. Trivial when compared to much larger issues in our world, but it is such a conflict for me. We've been Paleo for 12 days now and my body feels good. Better than when I was eating grains? Not sure yet, not enough time to tell. But even without the rice I am still alive and kipping (well, that awkward movement I make which would slightly resemble a kip) so that's a good sign. WANG

nick conn
nick conn

it's like ROUS's i dont think they exist.

The Claw
The Claw

One of the points of the Challenge is to find out how these things work for YOU. Like Travis, the last time I seriously undertook a Paleo Challenge I noted several good health outcomes, including normal blood lipids (first time ever), decrease in blood pressure from pre-hypertensive to normal, decrease in body fat, my psoriasis and dandruff cleared up, less daytime sleepiness, decrease in need for meds to control restless leg syndrome (yes, Nick Conn, it’s a real thing :-)), and probably a couple other things, too. Once the Challenge ended and I reverted to wheat, grains, tortillas, etc., that stuff started to come back. Hard to say whether it was the lack of wheat, the lack of dairy, or some combination of everything, but I know how it affects me. Nobody’s going to die by foregoing wheat for a couple of weeks, so consider the Challenge an experiment to see how limiting some of these items works out for you. Claw

Kari
Kari

great post guys. I'm going to show this (well, maybe just parts) to my husband to see if he'll join me for a few weeks of the challenge.

Travis
Travis

Word. I can tell you that my firsthand experience on this feels compelling. My hands used to crack and bleed until I did my first paleo challenge in January. Then they were healthy until June, when I caved and had a few beers to celebrate an awesome day of rock climbing. Guess what happened to my hands a few days later. Yup. Cracking again. And it wasn't the climbing, I do that all the time. I haven't been diagnosed with any kind of autoimmune disease, but I know from experience that my life is better when I do not eat wheat. Thanks for the comprehensive post, T&E.